Serviços Personalizados
Journal
Artigo
Indicadores
-
Citado por SciELO -
Acessos
Links relacionados
-
Similares em
SciELO
Compartilhar
Revista de la Facultad de Ingeniería Universidad Central de Venezuela
versão impressa ISSN 0798-4065
Rev. Fac. Ing. UCV v.20 n.2 Caracas maio 2005
Characterization study of the CO-AG SYSTEM obtained by mechanical alloying
D. BONYUET*, G. GONZÁLEZ**, ***, J. OCHOA**, R. VILLALBA**, C. ALBANO****
*Instituto de Investigación en Biomedicina y Ciencias Aplicadas, Universidad de Oriente, Cumaná,
**Laboratorio de Ciencia e Ingenieria de Materiales, Departamento de Ingenieria, Instituto Venezolano de Investigaciones Científicas, Aptdo. 21827, Caracas 1020ª
***Dpto. Física, Facultad. de Ciencias, Universidad Central de Venezuela, ,
****Escuela de Ingeniería Química, Facultad de Ingeniería, Universidad Central de Venezuela
ABSTRACT
Mechanical alloying (MA) is one of the methods employed for the synthesis of nanocrystalline alloys. In recent years, this technique has shown to be a versatile tool to prepare solid solutions in binary systems immiscible in equilibrium. The phase diagram of Co and Ag shows that the mutual solubility is very low in both the solid and liquid states. Therefore, no stable alloys of appreciable compositions exist under equilibrium conditions. Mixtures for different compositions of Co-Ag were studied by x-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). However, it was found that it is possible to obtain some partial solid solution in this system. This is confirmed by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC).
Keywords: mechanical alloying, ball milling, immiscible systems, Co-Ag.
ESTUDIOS DE LA CARACTERIZACIÓN DEL SISTEMA Co-Ag OBTENIDO POR ALEACIÓN MECÁNICA
RESUMEN
La aleación mecánica (AM) es uno de los métodos empleados para la síntesis de aleaciones nanocristalinas. En años recientes, esta técnica ha demostrado ser una herramienta versátil para preparar soluciones sólidas en sistemas binarios inmiscibles en el equilibrio. El diagrama de fase de Co y Ag muestra que la solubilidad mutua es muy baja tanto en el estado líquido como en el sólido. Por consiguiente, ninguna aleación de composición apreciable existiría bajo condiciones de equilibrio. Mezclas de diferentes composiciones de Co-Ag fueron estudiadas por difracción de rayos-x (DRX), microscopía electrónica de barrido (MEB), y microscopía electrónica de transmisión (MET). Sin embargo, se encontró que es posible obtener alguna solución sólida parcial en este sistema. Esto es confirmado por los resultados de calorimetría diferencial de barrido (CDB).
Palabras claves: aleación mecánica, molienda por bolas, sistemas inmiscibles, Co-Ag
Recibido: Julio de 2004 Recibido en forma final revisado :Junio 2005
INTRODUCTION
The synthesis of metastable phases by high energy ball milling has been studied extensively in recent years since this technique has proven to be a versatile tool to prepare solid solutions in binary systems immiscible in equilibrium, which are characterized by a large positive heat of mixing. Actually it is known that high-energy ball milling of the elemental powders induce alloying through large plastic deformation, cold welding, repeated fracturing and rewelding. By comparison with others techniques such as sputtering or vapor deposition, mechanical alloying has the advantages of relative low temperature processing, low cost, easy control of composition and the possibility of large sample volume.
In alloy systems with negative heat of mixing, the phase formation is quite understood and is explained by an interdiffusional reaction occurring during milling. On the other hand, in the case of systems with positive heat of mixing, phase formation is still subject of controversy, since in these systems a diffusional reaction results in decomposition of the alloy. However, formation of partial solid solutions in several systems with positive heat of mixing, including Fe-Ag [1-6], Fe-Cu [7-12], Co-Cu [13], Cu-Ta [14,15], Cu-W [16], and Ag-Cu [17,18] have been observed. For the Co-Ag system, we have found only one paper using MA [19], although there are some studies on sputtering in this system [20,21].
In the present work different compositions of Co-Ag, 10, 30 and 75 wt% Ag, milled during 10, 20 and 40 h, in a SPEX 8000 mixer/mill, under nitrogen atmosphere, were studied by x-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC).
EXPERIMENTAL METHOD
Commercial elemental powders of Ag and Co with 99.9% purity and initial particle size around than 50 mm were blended at the desired composition (10, 30 and 75 wt% Ag ). The milling was carried out using a SPEX 8000 mixer/mill with hardened steel balls and vial. The mixer/mill was slightly modified in order to use a smaller vial, so the impact of the balls is more energetic. The ball-to-powder weight ratio was 9:1. In the milling procedure 1 g of sample was used in every case and the vial was sealed in a nitrogen atmosphere and tightly clamped to prevent oxidation. The vial was processed for times of 10, 20 and 40 h, and the mill was operated by repeating a cycle of half hour period, interspersed with cooling down periods of also half hour. A new sample was used for each processing time in order to avoid possible air contamination due to the repeated opening of the vial.
The phase transformation in the ball-milled powders was followed by x-ray diffraction (XRD), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The XRD patterns were taken in a Siemens D5000 diffractometer using a Cu Ka (Ni filter) radiation. The Scherrer formula [22] given by Eq. (1) was used to estimated the crystallite grain size after milling
(1)
where q 0 is the diffraction angle and l the wavelength. The half width at half maximum D(2q) of the peaks were corrected for instrumental broadening by deducting the corresponding D(2q) produced by the initial pure components.
Specimens for transmission electron microscopy (TEM) have been prepared by embedding the powders in epoxy resin. Thin sections were taken by ultramicrotomy procedures. Observations have been made with a Philips CM12 microscope operating at 120 kV. Specimens for scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were prepared by
Embedding powders in epoxy resin, and further
metallographically polishing by usual methods. The SEM observations were carried out on a Philips LX30 microscope.
Thermal analysis of the samples was performed using a differential scanning calorimeter (Mettler Toledo Star System) operating from room temperature to 500 ºC at a heating rate of 10 ºC per minute. Samples of powder between 6.1 to 9.8 mg were place in aluminum pans under a flow of nitrogen.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Fig. 1 shows the XRD patterns corresponding to 10, 30 and 75 wt% Ag for the different milling times. In the as-mixed powders, we can see all Co and Ag peaks. The Co peaks are a mixture of two phases, one is hcp and the other one is fcc. However, the hcp peaks disappear with milling. For Co-Ag, 10 wt% Ag, we found that Ag peaks disappear with milling time, leaving only Co fcc peaks. It seems that Ag can be dissolved in the Co to form a homogeneous Co-rich solution.
In the case of Co-Ag, 30 wt% Ag we found that there is a two phase mixture of Co-rich and Ag-rich fcc phases, even after extended milling. For Co-Ag, 75 wt% Ag we found that Co peaks disappear with milling, leaving Ag peaks. In this case, the Co is dissolved in the Ag to form a homogeneous Ag-rich solution. With increasing milling time, diffraction peaks of both Co and Ag broaden significantly, indicating the refinement of grain size.
We can also see a contamination of CoO, especially in the mixtures rich in Co and high milling time. Although, great care was taken in keeping the samples under inert atmosphere, when the samples are taken out of the glove box and sent to XRD, they enter in contact with air and probably oxidation occurs in this moment. Angiolini et al. [4] consider that a non-negligible oxygen contamination cannot be avoided with this processing method.
After 10 h of MA the particle size becomes very small, the average particle size for 10 wt% Ag is 14 nm and after 40 h was of the order of 10 nm. For 30 wt% Ag, after 10 and 40 h the particle size is 7 nm and 5 nm, respectively. Finally, for 75 wt% Ag, the particle size is 11 nm for 10 h and 10 nm for 40 h of milling time. Therefore, milling is a very effective method to decrease particle size and the process tends to reach a steady state after some time.
Fig. 2 TEM bright field images of Co-Ag alloys milled from 10 to 40 h
Milling for the different periods was followed by TEM and SEM. TEM analyses are shown in the Fig. 2. The particle distribution and mixing with milling time is observed, and the Co particle size decreases faster than the Ag particle size. Homogeneity is reached after prolonged milling, the average particle size is 12 nm for all the compositions milled after 10 h and keeps constant up to 40 h. In the sample of Co-Ag, 10 wt% Ag, 10 h, Co and Ag crystals are observed, and the presence of Moire fringes over the Co crystals suggest the presence of Co oxide. The electron diffraction pattern shows texture in the rings due preferred deformation, and separated reflections of Co and Ag appear shifted, indicating probably the formation partial solid solution.
For the sample of Co-Ag, 30 wt% Ag, 10 h, there is uniform distribution of Ag particles. for Co-Ag, 30 wt% Ag, 40 h, the particle size in much smaller, and the electron diffraction pattern shows that peaks of Co had disappear and the Ag reflections are slightly shifted. This indicates dissolution of Co in Ag. For the sample of Co-75% Ag, 10 and 40 h, the Co particles seem to be completely covered by Ag. This was observed clearly in the SEM. The TEM of this samples show no differentiated particles of Co and Ag, but rather uniform particles. The electron diffraction patterns show only Ag reflections but slightly shifted. In all cases, polycrystalline and segregated Ag and Co fcc were found, with sharp peaks indicating well-crystallized phases. Electron diffraction of Co-Ag, 75 wt% Ag, samples show clearly the transformation of Co from hcp to fcc.
All the DSC data for Co-Ag are shown in the Fig. 3. All show exothermic peaks in the range from RT to 500 ºC, corresponding to the heat expelled by the mixtures corresponding to the released energy stored during milling. There is always a little sharp peak at about 235 ºC, which probably corresponds to the Co transformation from fcc to hcp. For all compositions, the area under the curves increases with milling time, which implies a higher stored energy during milling and therefore a higher released energy with heating.
The DSC curves of the Co-10 wt% Ag and Co-30 wt% Ag , are quite similar. However, the Co-75 wt% Ag shows a broad peak centered at about 400 ºC which seems to be an envelope of two peaks. This peak shifts towards lower temperatures with milling time and corresponds to deformation energy released during heating. Since there is more energy accumulated with milling time it will release at lower temperature on heating. Probably this peak is due to the decomposition of a partial solid solution of Co-Ag formed during milling at the interface.
CONCLUSIONS
Uniform distribution of Ag particles of nanometer size embedded in Co particles or vice-versa, depending on the composition of the samples, is achieved after periods as short as 10 h of ball milling. A mutual dispersion of Ag and Co is obtained. This is confirmed by DSC, which shows phase transformation. Our results are in agreement with those Yasuna et al. [19]. Further studies are being carried out in this system for a better understanding of the alloy formation by mechanical alloying.
REFERENCES
1. NASU S., P. H. SHINGU, K. N. ISHIHARA, AND F. E. FUJITA. 1990. Mössbauer study on mixing and kneading of metallic powders. Hyperfine Interactions, 55; 1043-1050.
2. NASU S. , S. MORIMOTO, H. TANIMOTO, B. HUANG, T. TANAKA, J. KUYAMA, K. N. ISHIHARA, AND P. H. SHINGU. 1991. Mössbauer study on mechanically alloyed powders. Hyperfine Interactions, 67; 681-686.
3. KUYAMA J., H. INUI, S. IMAOKA, S. NASU, K. N. ISHIHARA, AND P. H. SHINGU. 1991. Nanometer-sized formed by mechanical alloying in the Ag-Fe system. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics. 30(5A); L 854-L856.
4. ANGIOLINI M., A. DERIU, F. MALIZIA, G. MAZZONE, A. MONTONE, F. RONCONI, M. VITTORI-ANTISARI, AND J. S. PEDERSEN. 1997. Structural refinement of Af-Fe blends during high energy ball milling. Materials Science Forum, 269-272; 397-402.
5. COHEN N. S., E. AHLSWEDE, J. D. WICKS, AND Q. A. PANKHURST. 1997. Investigation of the ternary phase diagram of mechanically alloyed FeCuAg. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 9; 3259-3276.
6. E. MA, J.-H. HE, AND P. J. SCHILLING. 1997. Mechanical alloying of immiscible elements: Ag-Fe contrasted with Cu-Fe. Physical Review. B 55; 5542-5545.
7. UENISHI K., K. F. KOBAYASHI, S. NASU, H. HATANO, K. N. ISHIHARA, AND P. H. SHINGU. 1992. Mechanical alloying in the Fe-Cu system. Zeitschrift für Metallkunde, 83; 132-135.
8. A. R. YAVARI, P. J. DESRÉ, AND T. BENAMEUR. 1992. Mechanical driven alloying of immiscible elements. Physical Review Letters, 68(14), 2235-2238.
9. J. ECKERT, J. C. HOLZER, C. E. KRILL III, AND W. L. JOHNSON. 1993. Mechanically driven alloying and grain size changes in nanocrystalline Fe-Cu powders. Journal of Applied Physics. 73, 2794-2802.
10. MA E. , M. ATZMON, AND F. E. PINKERTON. 1993. Thermodynamic and magnetic properties of metastable FexCu100-x solid solutions formed by mechanical alloying. Journal of Applied Physics, 74(2); 955-962.
11. HUANG J. Y., A. Q. HE, Y. K. WU, H. Q. YE, AND D. X. LI. 1996. Structure evolution in the Cu-Fe system during mechanical alloying. Journal of Materials Science, 31; 4165-4169.
12. J. Z. JIANG, C. GENTE, AND R. BORMANN. 1998. Mechanical alloying in the Fe-Cu system. Materials Science and Engineering, A 242; 268-277.
13. C. GENTE, M. OEHRING, AND R. BORMANN. 1993. Formation of thermodynamically unstable solid solutions in the Cu-Co system by mechanical alloying. Physical Review, B 48; 13244-13252.
14. G. VELT, B. SCHOLZ, AND H.-D. KUNZE. 1991. Amorphization of Cu-Ta alloys by mechanical alloying. Materials Science and Engineering, A 134; 1410-1413.
15. K. SAKURAI, Y. YAMADA, C. H. LEE, T. FUKUNAGA, AND U. MIZUTANI. 1991. Solid state amorphization in the Cu-Ta alloy system. Materials Science and Engineering, A 134; 1414-1417.
16. GAFFET K., C. LOUISON, M. HARMELIN, AND F. FAUDOT. 1991. Metastable phase transformation induced by ball-milling in the Cu-W system. Materials Science and Engineering, A 134; 1380-1384.
17. UENISHI K., K. F. KOBAYASHI, K. N. ISHIHARA, AND P. H. SHINGU. 1991. Formation of a super-saturated solid solution in the Ag-Cu system by mechanical alloying Materials Science and Engineering, A 134; 1342-1345.
18. R. NAJAFABADI, D. J. SROLOVITZ, E. MA, AND M. ATZMON. 1993. Thermodynamic properties of metastable Ag-Cu alloys. Journal of Applied Physics, 74(5); 3144-3149.
19. YASUNA K., A. OTSUKI, K. N. ISHIHARA, AND P. H. SHINGU. 1997. Study of magnetoresistance in nano-structured Co-Ag alloys produced by mechanical alloying. Materials Science Forum, 235-238; 825-830.
20. XIAO J. Q., J. S. JIANG, C. L. CHIEN. 1992. Giant magnetoresistance in the granular Co-Ag system. Physical Review, B46; 9266-9269.
21. XIONG P., G. XIAO, J. Q. WANG, J. Q. XIAO, J. S. JIANG, C. L. CHIEN.1992. Extraordinary Hall effect and giant magnetoresistance in the granular Co-Ag system. Physical Review Letters, 69(22); 3220-3223.
22. GUINIER A. 1994. X-Ray Diffraction in Crystals, Imperfect Crystals, and Amorphous Bodies. Dover, New York, p. 143.















